Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers for study
and commentary. Answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC
keys — see the disclaimer.
You are a Public Information Officer (PIO) in a government department. You are aware that the RTI Act 2005 envisages transparency and accountability in administration. The act has functioned as a check on the supposedly arbitrarily administrative behaviour and actions. However, as a PIO you have observed that there are citizens who filed RTI applications not for themselves but on behalf of such stakeholders who purportedly want to have access to information to further their own interests. At the same time there are these RTI activists who routinely file RTI applications and attempt to extort money from the decision makers. This type of RTI activism has affected the functioning of the administration adversely and also possibly jeopardises the genuineness of the applications which are essentially aimed at getting justice.
What measures would you suggest to separate genuine and non-genuine applications? Give merits and demerits of your suggestions.
(Figure-based case study — image not shown here.) (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
As PIO, measures to separate genuine and non-genuine RTI applications could include examining the nature and public interest of the request, checking whether the applicant is seeking personal information of a third party to harass or extort, using the exemptions under Section 8 and the public interest test, consulting the applicant to clarify intent, maintaining records of repeated frivolous or extortionate filings, and taking legal recourse against extortion attempts. Merits include protecting genuine applicants and administration, preventing misuse and extortion, and upholding privacy. Demerits include the risk of arbitrary rejection, discouraging legitimate activism, diluting transparency and creating scope for officials to suppress inconvenient requests. Conclude that a careful, transparent and rights-respecting approach, with legal safeguards, is needed to distinguish genuine from non-genuine applications.
A building permitted for three floors, while being extended illegally to 6 floors by a builder, collapses. As a consequence, a number of innocent labourers including women and children died. These labourers are migrants of different places. The government immediately announced cash relief to the aggrieved families and arrested the builder.
Give reasons for such incidents taking place across the country. Suggest measures to prevent their occurrence. (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
Reasons for such building collapse incidents include illegal and unauthorised construction and violations of building bye-laws, corruption and collusion between builders and officials, weak enforcement and inspection, inadequate regulation and penalties, use of substandard materials, lack of structural audits, rapid unplanned urbanisation, and the vulnerability of migrant labour living in unsafe conditions. Measures to prevent them include strict enforcement of building codes and master plans, transparent approvals and inspections, strong penalties and accountability for officials and builders, mandatory structural audits and third-party certification, occupational safety for workers, registration and welfare of migrant labour, use of technology for monitoring, and public awareness. Conclude that only strict regulation, accountability and ethical governance can prevent such tragedies.
You are the manager of a spare parts company A and you have to negotiate a deal with the manager of a large manufacturing company B. The deal is highly competitive and sealing the deal is critical for your company. The deal is being worked out over a dinner. After dinner the manager of manufacturing company B offered to drop you to the hotel in his car. On the way to hotel, he happens to hit motorcycle injuring the motorcyclist badly. You know the manager was driving fast and thus lost control. The law enforcement officer comes to investigate the issue and you are the sole eyewitness to it. Knowing the strict laws pertaining to road accidents you are aware that your honest account of the incident would lead to the prosecution of the manager and as a consequence the deal is likely to be jeopardised, which is of immense importance to your company.
What are the dilemmas you face? What will be your response to the situation? (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The dilemmas are between honesty and duty as an eyewitness versus the business deal critical to the company; between personal and corporate interest versus justice for the injured motorcyclist; and between loyalty to the manager and the rule of law. The ethical values at stake include truthfulness, integrity, justice, and responsibility to the injured. My response would be to give an honest and complete account of the incident to the law enforcement officer, ensuring the injured gets medical help, regardless of the deal's fate. A deal built on concealment of wrongdoing would be unethical and unsustainable, and the company's long-term reputation depends on integrity. I would inform my company transparently. Conclude that truth and justice must prevail over commercial expediency.
You are the head of the Human Resources department of an organisation. One day one of the workers died on duty. His family was demanding compensation. However, the company denied compensation because it was revealed in investigation that he was drunk at the time of the accident. The workers of the company went to strike demanding compensation for the family of the deceased. The Chairman of the management board has asked for your recommendation.
What recommendation would you provide the management?
Discuss the merits and demerits of each of the recommendations. (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The ethical issues include the worker's death on duty, the family's dependence, the finding of intoxication, worker solidarity and strike, and the company's legal and moral responsibility. Recommendation options: (1) deny compensation strictly as the worker was drunk, which is legally defensible but morally harsh and inflames the strike; (2) grant compensation despite intoxication, showing compassion and industrial peace but setting a precedent and ignoring contributory negligence; (3) grant ex-gratia or compassionate relief and support the family while not admitting liability, balancing law and humanity; (4) also strengthen safety and alcohol policies to prevent recurrence. The best recommendation is a compassionate, needs-based relief combined with policy reform. Conclude that the management should balance legal position with humanitarian responsibility and worker morale.
You are aspiring to become an IAS officer and you have cleared various stages and now you have been selected for the personal interview. On the day of the interview, on the way to the venue you saw an accident where a mother and child who happen to be your relatives were badly injured. They needed immediate help.
What would you have done in such a situation? Justify your action. (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The case poses a conflict between personal attachment and a career opportunity. The ethical issues include duty to help injured relatives in an emergency, the value of compassion, and the responsibility toward the interview. In such a situation, I would first ensure the injured receive immediate help, calling an ambulance and arranging assistance, and if necessary accompanying them, while informing the interview authorities about the emergency to seek accommodation or a later slot. The value of human life and compassion takes precedence over a career opportunity, and a mature institution would understand. Options include helping and missing the interview, arranging help while proceeding, or seeking a rescheduled interview. Conclude that compassion and duty to save life must come first, and honest communication can reconcile both obligations.
You are an honest and responsible civil servant. You often observe the following:
Examine the above statements with their merits and demerits. (a) There is a general perception that adhering to ethical conduct one may face difficulties to oneself and cause problems for the family, whereas unfair practices may help to reach the career goals. (b) When the number of people adopting unfair means is large, a small minority having a penchant towards ethical means makes no difference. (c) Sticking to ethical means is detrimental to the larger developmental goals (d) While one may not involve oneself in large unethical practices, but giving and accepting small gifts makes the system more efficient. (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The case involves four rationalisations for unethical conduct, each with merits and demerits. (a) The claim that ethics brings difficulties while unfair practices aid careers is partly true in the short term, since dishonesty may yield quick gains, but it ignores the long-term risks of guilt, loss of reputation, legal consequences and erosion of trust, and the inner peace of integrity. (b) The claim that a small ethical minority makes no difference ignores the power of example and cumulative change, though it reflects the real pressure of widespread corruption. (c) The claim that ethical means hinder development is false, since unethical shortcuts cause injustice, unsustainable outcomes and distrust. (d) The claim that small gifts improve efficiency is a rationalisation of petty corruption that erodes standards. Conclude that ethical conduct is ultimately more sustainable and that individual integrity matters despite difficult circumstances.
Discipline generally implies following the order and subordination. However, it may be counter-productive for the organisation. Discuss (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The statement means that discipline, understood only as following orders and subordination, can be counter-productive for an organisation. Blind obedience stifles initiative, creativity, critical thinking and innovation, discourages employees from reporting problems or suggesting improvements, and can perpetuate errors and unethical orders, as in bureaucracies that follow rules mindlessly. Excessive hierarchy reduces morale, accountability and adaptability. However, discipline also provides order, coordination and predictability, so the issue is the type of discipline. The answer should argue for a balance where discipline coexists with autonomy, voice and ethical judgement. Conclude that rigid, order-following discipline can harm organisations, so empowered and thoughtful discipline is preferable.
Increased national wealth did not result in equitable distribution of its benefits. It has created only some “enclaves of modernity and prosperity for a small minority at the cost of the majority.” Justify (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The statement is largely valid. Increased national wealth has not resulted in equitable distribution of benefits because growth has been concentrated in certain sectors, regions and groups, creating enclaves of modernity and prosperity for a small minority, such as urban elites, industrialists and skilled professionals, while the majority, including farmers, informal workers, tribals and the poor, remain excluded. Inequality, jobless growth, weak social spending, elite capture and unequal access to education and health perpetuate this divide. The answer should cite inequality and poverty data and examples such as gated prosperity amid slums. Conclude that growth must be made inclusive through redistribution, social investment and equitable opportunity.
Strength, peace and security are considered to be the pillars of international relations. Elucidate (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The statement means that strength, peace and security are the foundational pillars of international relations. Strength, military and economic, provides a nation the capability to protect its interests, deter aggression and negotiate from a position of power. Peace is the condition for stability, development and cooperation, and is pursued through diplomacy, dialogue and international institutions. Security ensures the survival, sovereignty and well-being of states and their people. Together they shape foreign policy, alliances, deterrence and global order, as seen in balance-of-power politics and collective security. The answer should note that these pillars can conflict, since the pursuit of strength may threaten peace. Conclude that a stable international order balances strength with peace and security.
Corporate social responsibility makes companies more profitable and sustainable. Analyse (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2017 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The statement argues that corporate social responsibility makes companies more profitable and sustainable, which is largely valid. CSR builds reputation and brand value, earns customer loyalty and goodwill, attracts talent and investment, reduces regulatory and community risk, improves employee morale and productivity, and ensures a social licence to operate, all of which support long-term profitability. It also promotes sustainability by addressing environmental and social impacts. The answer should note that CSR can be mere tokenism or greenwashing if not genuine, and that the Companies Act mandates CSR spending. Conclude that genuine CSR enhances both profitability and sustainability, aligning business success with social good.