Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers for study
and commentary. Answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC
keys — see the disclaimer.
You are the Executive Director of an upcoming InfoTech Company which is making a name for itself in the market.
Mr. A, who is a star performer, is heading the marketing team. In a short period of one year, he has helped in doubling the revenues as well as creating a high brand equity for the Company so much so that you are thinking of promoting him. However, you have been receiving information from many corners about his attitude towards the female colleagues; particularly his habit of making loose comments on women. In addition, he regularly sends indecent SMS’ to all the team members including his female colleagues.
One day, late in the evening, Mrs. X, who is one of Mr. A’s team members, comes to you visibly disturbed. She complains against the continued misconduct of Mr. A, who has been making undesirable advances towards her and has even tried to touch her inappropriately in his cabin. She tenders her resignation and leaves your office. (i) What are the options available to you? (ii) Evaluate each of these options and choose the option you would adopt, giving reasons.
(Figure-based case study — image not shown here.) (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The case involves an Executive Director whose star marketing performer, Mr. A, is accused of sexual harassment by a female team member, Mrs. X, who also resigns, while Mr. A is being considered for promotion. The options available are: (i) ignore the complaint to retain the star performer, which is unethical, illegal, betrays the victim and creates a hostile workplace. (ii) confront and warn Mr. A privately without a formal inquiry, which is inadequate and does not follow due process. (iii) constitute an internal complaints committee as required by the POSH Act, 2013, conduct a fair, confidential and time-bound inquiry, protect the complainant from retaliation, and act on the findings, which upholds the law, justice and employee dignity. (iv) persuade Mrs. X to withdraw her resignation and assure her of a fair inquiry, which supports the victim. (v) take interim measures such as separating the parties and preventing further harassment. The best course is to follow the POSH Act, set up or refer to the internal committee, ensure a fair inquiry, protect the complainant, and take appropriate action against Mr. A if found guilty, regardless of his performance, while also promoting a safe workplace culture. Conclude that the director must act decisively under the POSH framework to ensure a fair inquiry and protect the victim, since no performance justifies tolerating harassment.
As a senior officer in the Finance Ministry, you have access to some confidential and crucial information about policy decisions that the Government is about to announce. These decisions are likely to have far-reaching impact on the housing and construction industry. If the builders have access to this information beforehand, they can make huge profits. One of the builders has done a lot of quality work for the Government and is known to be close to your immediate superior, who asks you to disclose this information to the said builder. (i) What are the options available to you? (ii) Evaluate each of these options and choose the option which you would adopt, giving reasons. (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The case involves a senior Finance Ministry officer being asked by an immediate superior to disclose confidential, market-sensitive information about an upcoming policy decision to a builder close to the superior. The options available are: (i) comply and disclose the information, which is illegal, a breach of confidentiality and official secrets, insider trading and corruption, benefiting a private party and harming the public and the market, though it may please the superior. (ii) refuse clearly and explain that disclosure is illegal and unethical, which upholds the law and integrity but may invite the superior's displeasure. (iii) refuse and, if the superior persists, report the matter in writing to higher authorities or the appropriate vigilance or anti-corruption body, which upholds the law and protects the officer but is confrontational. (iv) seek written orders or record the superior's direction to protect oneself, which documents the illegality. (v) seek guidance from the designated authority or legal adviser. The best course is to firmly refuse, keep a written record of the request and the refusal, and if necessary report the matter, since confidentiality and the public interest must be protected. Conclude that the officer must refuse to disclose the confidential information and uphold the law, reporting any persistence through proper channels.
You are heading a leading technical institute of the country. The institute is planning to convene an interview panel shortly under your chairmanship for selection of the post of professors. A few days before the interview, you get a call from the Personal Secretary (PS) of a senior government functionary seeking your intervention in favour of the selection of a close relative of the functionary for this post. The PS also informs you that he is aware of the long pending and urgent proposals of your institute for grant of funds for modernization, which are awaiting the functionary’s approval. He assures you that he would get these proposals cleared. (i) What are the options available to you? (ii) Evaluate each of these options and choose the option which you would adopt, giving reasons. (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The case involves a call from the PS of a senior government functionary seeking intervention in favour of a relative in a professorial selection, in exchange for clearing pending modernisation funds. The options available are: (i) comply and select the relative, which is illegal, unethical and violates merit and fairness, and amounts to corruption, though it secures funds. (ii) refuse firmly and select on merit, upholding integrity and merit but risking the funds and possible official displeasure. (iii) politely decline to interfere, explaining that selection is done by the panel on merit, and separately pursue the pending proposals through proper channels, which protects both integrity and the institute's interests. (iv) report the improper request to higher authorities or the appropriate authority, which upholds the law but may be confrontational. (v) seek to buy time or delay, which avoids the decision but is not a real solution. The best course is to firmly refuse any interference, ensure a fair and merit-based selection, keep a record, pursue the funds transparently, and if pressure continues, report the matter. Conclude that merit and integrity must not be compromised, and the right option is to reject the improper request and pursue the funds through lawful means.
Sivakasi in Tamil Nadu is known for its manufacturing clusters on firecrackers and matches. The local economy of the area is largely dependent on firecrackers industry. It has led to tangible economic development and improved standard of living in the area.
So far as child labour norms for hazardous industries like firecrackers industry are concerned, International Labour Organization (ILO) has set the minimum age as 18 years. In India, however, this age is 14 years.
The units in industrial clusters of firecrackers can be classified into registered and non-registered entities. One typical unit is household-based work. Though the law is clear on the use of child labour employment norms in registered/non-registered units, it does not include household-based works. Household-based work means children working under the supervision of their parents/relatives. To evade child labour norms, several units project themselves as household-based works but employ children from outside. Needless to say that employing children saves the costs for these units leading to higher profits to the owners.
On your visit to one of the units at Sivakasi, the owner takes you around the unit which has about 10-15 children below 14 years of age. The owner tells you that in his household-based unit, the children are all his relatives. You notice that several children smirk, when the owner tells you this. On deeper enquiry, you figure out that neither the owner nor the children are able to satisfactorily establish their relationship with each other. (i) Bring out and discuss the ethical issues involved in the above case. (ii) What would be your reaction after your above visit? (25 marks, 300 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The case involves child labour in the firecracker industry in Sivakasi, where the owner claims children below 14 are relatives in a household-based unit, which appears to be a ruse to evade child labour laws. (i) The ethical issues involved include the exploitation and endangerment of children in a hazardous industry, violation of child labour norms and the right to education, the health and safety risks of handling explosives, the use of a legal loophole in household-based work to evade the law, the conflict between the local economy and children's welfare, the complicity of owners motivated by profit, and the state's responsibility to protect children, as well as the ethical duty of the visiting official. (ii) After the visit, my reaction would be to firmly record the facts and not be misled by the claim of relationship, verify the children's ages and identities, initiate action under the Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act and the juvenile justice law, inform the district administration and child welfare authorities, ensure the children's rescue, rehabilitation and education, and recommend inspection of other units, while also promoting awareness among parents about the harms of child labour and supporting their livelihoods. Conclude that the case demands strict enforcement against child labour and a humane, rights-based response that protects children and addresses the economic compulsions.
You are working as an Executive Engineer in the construction cell of a Municipal Corporation and are presently in-charge of the construction of a flyover. There are two Junior Engineers under you who have the responsibility of day-to-day inspection of the site and are reporting to you, while you are finally reporting to the Chief Engineer who heads the cell.
While the construction is heading towards completion, the Junior Engineers have been regularly reporting that all construction is taking place as per design specifications. However, in one of your surprise inspections, you have noticed some serious deviations and lacunae which, in your opinion, are likely to affect the safety of the flyover. Rectification of these lacunae at this stage would require a substantial amount of demolition and rework which will cause a tangible loss to the contractor and will also delay completion. There is a lot of public pressure on the Corporation to get this construction completed because of heavy traffic congestion in the area. When you brought this matter to the notice of the Chief Engineer, he advised you that in his opinion it is not a very serious lapse and may be ignored. He advised for further expediting the project for completion in time. However, you are convinced that this was a serious matter which might affect public safety and should not be left unaddressed.
What will you do in such a situation? Some of the options are given below. Evaluate the merits and demerits of each of these options and finally suggest what course of action you would like to take, giving reasons. (i) Follow the advice of the Chief Engineer and go ahead. (ii) Make an exhaustive report of the situation bringing out all facts and analysis along with your own viewpoints stated clearly and seek for written orders from the chief Engineer. (iii) Call for explanation from the Junior Engineers and issue orders to the contractor for necessary correction within targeted time. (iv) Highlight the issue so that it reaches superiors above the Chief Engineer. (v) Considering the rigid attitude of the Chief Engineer, seek transfer from the project or report sick. (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The case involves an Executive Engineer who finds serious deviations and lacunae in a flyover that may affect public safety, while the Chief Engineer advises ignoring them and expediting completion under public pressure. Evaluating the options: (i) following the Chief Engineer's advice abdicates responsibility and endangers public life, and is professionally and ethically wrong. (ii) making an exhaustive report with facts, analysis and one's own viewpoint and seeking written orders is the best option, as it documents the concern, fixes responsibility, protects against future blame and forces a transparent decision. (iii) calling for explanation from the Junior Engineers and ordering the contractor to correct within a time frame addresses the immediate lapse but may be insufficient if the deviations are serious and the superior's concurrence is needed. (iv) highlighting the issue to superiors above the Chief Engineer is a valid escalation if the Chief Engineer refuses to act, and protects public safety. (v) seeking transfer or reporting sick is escapism and abandons the duty to protect public safety. The right course is to prepare a detailed written report, seek written orders, and if necessary escalate to higher authorities, while ensuring that the safety issue is addressed. Conclude that public safety must prevail over convenience, and the engineer should document, escalate and ensure rectification rather than comply with an unsafe order.
A Public Information Officer has received an application under RTI Act. Having gathered the information, the PIO discovers that the information pertains to some of the decisions taken by him, which were found to be not altogether right. There were other employees also who party to these decisions were. Disclosure of the information is likely to lead to disciplinary action with possibility of punishment against him as well as some of his colleagues. Non-disclosure or part disclosure or camouflaged disclosure of information will result into lesser punishment or no punishment.
The PIO is otherwise an honest and conscientious person but this particular decision, on which the RTI application has been filed, turned out to be wrong. He comes to you for advice.
The following are some suggested options. Please evaluate the merits and demerits of each of the options:
Also please indicate (without necessarily restricting to the above options) what you would like to advise, giving proper reasons. (i) The PIO could refer the matter to his superior officer and seek his advice and act strictly in accordance with the advice, even though he is not completely in agreement with the advice of the superior. (ii) The PIO could proceed on leave and leave the matter to be dealt by his successor in office or request for transfer of the application to another PIO. (iii) The PIO could weigh the consequences of disclosing the information truthfully, including the effect on his career, and reply in a manner that would not place him or his career in jeopardy, but at the same time a little compromise can be made on the contents of the information. (iv) The PIO could consult his other colleagues who are party to the decision and take action as per their advice. (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The case involves a PIO who finds that information sought under RTI concerns his own wrong decisions, disclosure of which could lead to disciplinary action against him and colleagues, while non-disclosure or partial disclosure could reduce punishment. Evaluating the options: (i) referring the matter to the superior and acting on his advice dilutes personal responsibility, may be safe but can lead to improper advice and abdication of duty. (ii) proceeding on leave or seeking transfer avoids the dilemma but is escapism, delays disclosure and shirks accountability. (iii) weighing consequences and replying in a manner that protects one's career while compromising the information is dishonest, violates the RTI Act, betrays public trust and is a self-serving cover-up. (iv) consulting colleagues who are party to the decision risks collusion to conceal the truth. The right course is to uphold the RTI Act and truthfully disclose the information, accept responsibility for the wrong decision, and face the consequences with integrity, since the duty to the citizen and the law overrides personal interest. Conclude that the PIO should disclose the information honestly, uphold the law and public trust, and face the consequences rather than compromise on truth.
It is often said that ‘politics’ and ‘ethics’ do not go together. What is your opinion in this regard? Justify your answer with illustrations (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The statement that politics and ethics do not go together reflects the common perception that politics is driven by power, self-interest, manipulation and expediency rather than moral principles. My opinion is that politics and ethics should and can go together, though they often do not. Ethics is essential in politics because politics concerns the governance of society and the use of public power, so honesty, accountability, justice and service to the people must guide it. Illustrations of ethical politics include leaders such as Mahatma Gandhi, Nelson Mandela and Abraham Lincoln, who upheld principles, and leaders who resigned or refused to compromise on values. Counter-examples of unethical politics include corruption, criminalisation, communal polarisation, populism and abuse of power, which erode democracy. Realistic politics involves balancing ideals with practical constraints, but core ethical principles must not be sacrificed. Conclude that while politics is often seen as divorced from ethics, ethical politics is both possible and necessary, and must be strengthened through accountability and moral leadership.
Bring out what the given quotation means to you in the present context. “Nearly all men can withstand adversity, but if you want to test a man’s character, give him power.”—Abraham Lincoln (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
Lincoln's quotation means that adversity is a relatively easy test of a person, since many can endure hardship, but power is the true test of character, because power reveals a person's real nature and tempts them to abuse it. When given power, the weak or self-serving may become arrogant, corrupt, oppressive and self-indulgent, while those of genuine character remain humble, just, restrained and service-oriented. In the present context, it applies to political leaders, civil servants, corporate heads, police and officials, whose true character is exposed by how they use power, whether for the public good or personal gain. It also applies to ordinary people in positions of authority, such as parents and teachers. Conclude that power is the ultimate test of character, and true character is shown by the wise, ethical and restrained use of power for the common good.
What is ‘emotional intelligence’ and how can it be developed in people? How does it help an individual in taking ethical decisions? (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
Emotional intelligence is the ability to recognise, understand, manage and use one's own emotions and to perceive, understand and respond to the emotions of others. It includes self-awareness, self-regulation, motivation, empathy and social skills. It can be developed in people through self-reflection and mindfulness, education and training in emotional and social skills from childhood, counselling and feedback, practice in empathy and active listening, exposure to diverse situations and people, meditation and stress management, role models and mentoring, and a supportive environment that encourages emotional expression and regulation. It helps an individual in taking ethical decisions because it promotes self-awareness of one's biases and feelings, self-regulation to resist anger, greed and pressure, empathy to consider the impact on others, better judgement in dilemmas, and the courage and composure to act on moral conviction rather than impulse. Conclude that emotional intelligence can be developed through reflection, training and practice, and it greatly aids ethical decision-making by balancing emotion and reason.
Indicate two attributes which you consider important for public service. Justify your answer (10 marks, 100 words)
UPSC CSE 2013 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
Two attributes I consider important for public service are integrity and empathy. Integrity, meaning honesty, uprightness and consistency between values and actions, is essential because public servants hold power and public resources in trust, and integrity ensures that power is used for the public interest, prevents corruption and abuse, maintains public trust and provides an example to society, since a public servant without integrity destroys the credibility of the entire system. Empathy, meaning the ability to understand and feel the situation of others, is essential because public service exists to serve citizens, especially the poor and vulnerable, and empathy enables a civil servant to be humane, sensitive to ground realities, responsive to the needs of the disadvantaged, and to design and deliver services with compassion rather than indifference. Together they make administration both honest and humane. Conclude that integrity and empathy are vital attributes because they ensure that public service is both trustworthy and compassionate.