The DM should not unilaterally use an unproven supplement on a vulnerable tribe. Medical ethics require informed consent, precaution, evidence of safety and efficacy, independent ethics review and equitable access; administrative ethics require legality, non-maleficence and avoidance of exploitation. The DM should facilitate a properly approved clinical trial or compassionate-use protocol with community consent, monitoring and independent oversight, while arranging established care and avoiding therapeutic misconception.
Previous Year Questions
Prelims questions are objective MCQs; Mains questions are descriptive and test answer writing. Choose a stage, then filter by subject, topic and year.
Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers for study and commentary. Answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the disclaimer.
The officer faces conflicts between development and the community's rights to land, livelihood, culture and habitat; between legal procedure and substantive consent; and between pressure from the business house and the duty to act impartially. Other challenges include compensation and rehabilitation, environmental clearance, intergenerational equity, corruption and the risk of protest. Ethical handling requires free prior informed consent, transparent impact assessment, fair compensation, resettlement and grievance redress, with the officer insulated from undue influence.
Using AI to generate a PhD evaluation and submitting it with minor edits raises issues of accountability, academic integrity, transparency, competence and fairness to the candidate. The professor remains responsible for the judgement, yet AI-generated comments may be inaccurate, biased or unverifiable. The ethical course is to disclose permissible AI assistance, independently read the thesis, verify every claim, follow the university's evaluation norms and refuse to delegate the core evaluative judgement to a machine.
Charity is a voluntary, supererogatory act; duty is an obligation that can be morally demanded. Philosophers such as Singer argue that if we can prevent serious suffering at little cost to ourselves, we are morally obligated to do so, so giving becomes a duty rather than optional generosity. The distinction lies in enforceability, motivation and the marginal sacrifice involved; resources spent on luxuries while others lack basic needs raise a strong moral claim, even if legal enforcement is a separate question.
Gandhi's trusteeship asks those with wealth, power or office to hold it in trust for society rather than treat it as private property. An IAS officer can apply it by using discretionary powers for public benefit, avoiding self-enrichment, ensuring equitable access to services, consulting affected communities, promoting simplicity and transparency, and treating subordinates and citizens with dignity. Fairness results when authority is exercised as a responsibility towards the weakest, not as a privilege.
Ambedkar feared that civil disobedience outside constitutional channels could legitimise anarchy and undermine the very democracy needed for social reform. Modern democracies should distinguish peaceful, rights-based protest from violence, protect the right to dissent, and require proportionality, exhaustion of lawful remedies and willingness to negotiate. Civil disobedience can be ethically justified against grave injustice when it is non-violent, public, targeted at unjust laws and accepts legal consequences; the state should respond with dialogue and reform, not repression.
Empathy requires understanding the teacher's family situation and the child's need for care, but compliance requires that transfers, postings and private tuition follow rules and avoid conflict of interest. The DM's intervention, made at his PA's request, risks nepotism and arbitrariness. A defensible approach is to use lawful discretion transparently, record reasons, consider a general policy for caregivers of children with disabilities, and avoid special favour to a relative of his PA.
Efficiency is about using resources well to do things right; effectiveness is about achieving the right public goals. A balance requires clarity of purpose, outcome-based indicators, quality standards, feedback from citizens, staff capacity and ethical use of resources. Productivity improves when processes are streamlined without sacrificing equity or quality, and when managers reward both speed and the achievement of meaningful results.
Paternalism is acting for another's good without their consent, while beneficence is the duty to promote their welfare. The doctor's action was beneficent in intent but paternalistic in method because pressure and selective information led the patient to a reluctant consent. Ethical practice requires shared decision-making, disclosure of risks and alternatives, respect for the patient's autonomous choice, and persuasion without coercion.
Ladakh's location between China and Pakistan makes border-area development a security and welfare imperative. BADP funds roads, schools, health facilities, water and connectivity to reduce isolation and build trust, while Army civic action provides medical camps, schooling and disaster relief. The demand for the Sixth Schedule seeks protection of land, culture and self-governance for tribal communities; it should be examined through constitutional safeguards, local consultation and balanced development rather than dismissed as separatism.