The answer should define parliamentary supremacy as the legislature's primacy in law-making and accountability, and cabinet government as collective executive responsibility to Parliament. The growth of the cabinet system has marginalised Parliament through executive dominance, whips and anti-defection, ordinances, money bills, guillotine procedure, centralisation in the PMO and the decline of private members' bills and sitting days. Yet Parliament retains no-confidence motions, committees, questions and the CAG. Suggest strengthening committees, ensuring minimum sittings, open debate and pre-legislative scrutiny to restore balance between cabinet efficiency and parliamentary supremacy.
Separation of Powers Between Various Organs, Dispute Redressal Mechanisms and Institutions — UPSC PYQs & Notes
Every previous year question on Separation of Powers Between Various Organs, Dispute Redressal Mechanisms and Institutions from Indian Polity & Governance, with answers and explanations.
Every PYQ on this topic
Attempt each question first, then reveal the answer and explanation.
Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers; answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the disclaimer.
Judicial independence means judges decide without executive or legislative pressure, protected by security of tenure, fixed salaries, difficult removal procedures and contempt powers. It is a prerequisite of democracy because courts protect rights, check arbitrary power, resolve federal disputes and uphold the Constitution. The answer should cite Articles 50, 124 and 217, the Judges cases and the basic structure doctrine. It should also acknowledge concerns about appointments, vacancies and accountability. Conclude that independence must be paired with transparency and efficiency to sustain public trust.
Parliament ensures executive accountability through question hour, motions, no-confidence votes, debates, committees, budget scrutiny and the CAG. Its effectiveness is limited by executive dominance, whips, anti-defection, disruptions, declining sittings, ordinance rule and the weakening of committees. The answer should give examples of strong committee reports and of disrupted sessions. Conclude that Parliament can hold the executive to account only if it functions with regularity, transparency and genuine debate, and if committees are strengthened.
The answer should explain that judicial legislation, where courts frame guidelines in the absence of law, can be seen as a breach of separation of powers. Yet PILs seeking guidelines are justified when the legislature and executive fail, rights are violated and vulnerable groups need protection, as in Vishaka on harassment, the right to food and environmental directions. The judiciary fills a vacuum, but excessive intervention raises concerns about accountability and expertise. The answer should recommend judicial restraint, structured guidelines and greater legislative responsiveness. Conclude that PIL is a corrective device, not a substitute for democratic law-making.
The answer should agree that the Indian Constitution does not follow a strict separation of powers but a system of checks and balances. The legislature, executive and judiciary have distinct functions, yet they interact: the executive is drawn from the legislature, the judiciary reviews laws and executive action, the legislature can impeach judges and the executive appoints them. Examples include judicial review, parliamentary accountability and the ordinance power. The answer should note that the Constitution blends separation with coordination. Conclude that this scheme prevents tyranny and ensures accountability rather than rigid compartmentalisation.
The Supreme Court keeps a check on the arbitrary power of Parliament in amending the Constitution through the basic structure doctrine, laid down in Kesavananda Bharati (1973), which holds that Parliament can amend the Constitution but cannot destroy its essential or basic features such as supremacy of the Constitution, republican and democratic form of government, secularism, federalism, separation of powers, judicial review, rule of law and free and fair elections. In Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain and Minerva Mills, the Court struck down amendments violating these features. This check upholds constitutionalism and protects fundamental rights and the balance of power. However, critics argue that judicial review of amendments is undemocratic, vague and can lead to judicial overreach, and that the basic structure is undefined. Conclude that while the check protects constitutional values against majoritarian excess, it must be exercised with restraint and clarity, balancing parliamentary sovereignty with constitutional supremacy.
Notes on this topic
Short, syllabus-aligned notes for a final pass before the exam.
No notes on this topic yet. The questions above all include explanations.