The Speaker's office has become vulnerable to partisanship, especially in anti-defection proceedings, recognition of leaders and control over legislative business, where rulings can favour the ruling party. Institutional changes should include time-bound decisions on disqualification, reasoned orders, judicial review, an independent presiding officer for anti-defection matters, transparent scheduling and stronger privileges committees. The goal is to combine the Speaker's disciplinary authority with neutrality and accountability.
Parliament and State Legislatures – Structure, Functioning, Conduct of Business, Powers and Privileges and Issues Arising out of these — UPSC PYQs & Notes
Every previous year question on Parliament and State Legislatures – Structure, Functioning, Conduct of Business, Powers and Privileges and Issues Arising out of these from Indian Polity & Governance, with answers and explanations.
Every PYQ on this topic
Attempt each question first, then reveal the answer and explanation.
Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers; answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the disclaimer.
The statement reflects the historical view that women are not a minority or a backward class but a group facing structural disadvantage across caste and class. Women's reservation evolved from 33 per cent in local bodies under the 73rd and 74th Amendments to the 2023 Act providing 33 per cent in the Lok Sabha and state assemblies, with a delayed commencement linked to census and delimitation. The answer should assess representation, substantive empowerment and the need for complementary measures.
After the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019, the former state became a Union Territory with a Legislative Assembly. The Assembly can legislate on state-list subjects delegated to it, except public order and police, and it has financial powers subject to central control. The answer should describe its composition, powers, limitations under the UT framework and the role of the Lieutenant Governor.
The parliamentary committee system includes standing committees, select committees, joint committees and ad hoc committees, with financial committees such as the Public Accounts Committee, Estimates Committee and Committee on Public Undertakings. These examine expenditure, audit reports, bills and policy, and provide detailed scrutiny that the full House cannot. Financial committees have strengthened institutional accountability, improved financial discipline and promoted oversight of public enterprises. Limitations include low referral of bills, weak follow-up and partisan influence. Conclude that committees are the workshop of Parliament and need more time, resources and independence.
Civil society groups contribute to women's political participation by training women candidates, building leadership skills, running voter awareness campaigns, supporting women's collectives and advocating for reservations and electoral reforms. They also monitor violence and discrimination, help women navigate party structures and connect them with constituents. Examples include women's movements, NGOs and SHG federations. Challenges include funding constraints, co-option and limited rural reach. The answer should recommend sustained capacity building, legal support and collaboration with election commissions, concluding that civil society complements formal institutions in deepening representative democracy.
Presiding officers of state legislatures maintain order, interpret rules, decide points of order, regulate debates and ensure that the opposition gets a fair chance. Impartiality is essential for the legitimacy of the House, especially in deciding disqualification under the Tenth Schedule and in recognizing party status. They also facilitate democratic practices such as question hour, committees and open discussion. The answer should note concerns about partisan rulings and the need for clear timelines in anti-defection cases. Conclude that the Speaker's credibility rests on fairness, transparency and respect for minority voices.
The Vice-President of India is the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. In that role, he presides over sittings, maintains order, interprets rules, decides points of order, refers bills to committees and exercises a casting vote in case of a tie. He also safeguards the rights of the opposition and the states. Unlike the Speaker, he is not a member of the House. The answer should note concerns about partisanship and the need for impartiality. Conclude that the Chairman's fairness is essential to the Upper House's role as a revising and federal chamber.
Department-related Parliamentary Standing Committees scrutinise bills, budgets, ministry performance and policy, question officials and produce reports. They keep administration on its toes by providing detailed, bipartisan oversight and continuity between sessions. Examples include reports on health, defence and education. Yet their effectiveness is limited by low referral of bills, poor attendance, short time and weak follow-up. The answer should conclude that committees inspire reverence for parliamentary control when they are strengthened, resourced and their recommendations are acted upon.
Legislative Councils are established under Article 169, which allows Parliament to create or abolish them on a resolution of the state legislative assembly. Their composition is governed by Article 171, with members elected by graduates, teachers, local bodies and MLAs, and nominated by the Governor. Working varies: some states have active councils, while others have abolished them. The answer should review their role as revising chambers and their criticism as expensive and redundant. Conclude that their value depends on meaningful deliberation and state-specific needs.
The Rajya Sabha was once dismissed as a 'useless stepney tyre' but has become a vital revising and federal chamber. Factors include its role in scrutinising bills, representing states, providing continuity between Lok Sabha terms, enabling expert and independent members, and acting as a check on hasty legislation. Visible areas include debates on key laws, committee work, and preventing the passage of controversial bills through scrutiny and referral. The answer should note criticisms of delay and political use. Conclude that the Rajya Sabha has evolved into an indispensable organ of deliberation and federal balance.
The practice of 'once a Speaker, always a Speaker', where the Speaker resigns from the party on election, is followed in the UK to ensure impartiality. Adopting it in India could improve objectivity, especially in anti-defection decisions and floor tests, and strengthen the House's credibility. Implications include reduced partisanship and better protection of opposition rights, but also practical challenges: the Speaker is elected as a party candidate, must contest again, and the Tenth Schedule requires a neutral arbiter. The answer should weigh these. Conclude that the practice merits consideration, but impartiality must also come from clear timelines and conventions.
The answer should agree that the individual parliamentarian's role as a national lawmaker has declined due to party discipline, whips, anti-defection, executive dominance, the decline of private members' bills, fewer sittings, disruptions, guillotine procedure and the centralisation of decision-making. This weakens the quality of debate and legislation, as bills are often passed with little scrutiny. Measures include strengthening committees, ensuring minimum sittings, protecting private members' bills, reforming anti-defection and promoting open debate. Conclude that restoring the legislator's role is essential for parliamentary democracy and better laws.
Committees are useful for parliamentary work because they provide detailed scrutiny of legislation and budgets, allow specialised, in-depth examination away from partisan floor debates, ensure continuity, enable expert and stakeholder consultation, and improve accountability and oversight of the executive. They reduce the burden on the full House and produce informed reports. The Estimates Committee, the largest committee of the Lok Sabha, examines the budget estimates to suggest economies, efficiency and administrative reform, and reports on whether money is well spent within the limits of policy. Its role is to scrutinise expenditure, not policy, and its recommendations guide financial administration. Conclude that committees, especially the Estimates Committee, strengthen legislative control over the purse.
A joint sitting of both Houses is provided under Article 108 to resolve a deadlock over an ordinary bill. It is normally held when the other House rejects the bill, disagrees on amendments, or allows more than six months to pass without passing it. It cannot be held for a Money Bill, since the Lok Sabha's decision prevails; for a Constitutional Amendment Bill, which requires separate special majorities in each House; and for a bill on which the President has already given assent. It is presided over by the Speaker. The answer should cite the examples of the Dowry Prohibition Bill 1961 and the Prevention of Terrorism Bill 2002. Conclude that the joint sitting is a mechanism to resolve legislative deadlock, with clear exceptions.
The Public Accounts Committee, a parliamentary committee, examines the audit reports of the CAG on the accounts of the Union, ensuring that public money is spent legally, economically and for approved purposes. It scrutinises the appropriation accounts, examines cases of irregularity, waste, corruption and financial impropriety, questions the executive and makes recommendations. It acts as the watchdog of the legislature over the executive's use of public funds, thereby establishing accountability to the people and strengthening financial oversight and transparency. The answer should note its limitations, such as not examining policy and lack of enforcement of recommendations. Conclude that the PAC is a key instrument of legislative accountability over the public purse.
Notes on this topic
Short, syllabus-aligned notes for a final pass before the exam.
No notes on this topic yet. The questions above all include explanations.