India follows a flexible separation of powers with functional overlap: the executive is part of the legislature, the judiciary reviews legislation and the bureaucracy implements policy. The US model is rigid, with a separately elected President, no parliamentary accountability and stronger checks. The Indian Prime Minister is the real executive, commanding a parliamentary majority and cabinet, while the US President is both head of state and government but faces congressional gridlock; actual authority differs because of party discipline, coalition politics and constitutional conventions.
Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of other Countries — UPSC PYQs & Notes
Every previous year question on Comparison of the Indian Constitutional Scheme with that of other Countries from Indian Polity & Governance, with answers and explanations.
Every PYQ on this topic
Attempt each question first, then reveal the answer and explanation.
Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers; answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the disclaimer.
In India, the President's pardoning power under Article 72 covers courts-martial, death sentences and union-law offences, and is exercised on ministerial advice, subject to judicial review for arbitrariness. In the USA, the President's pardon power under Article II is broader for federal offences, except impeachment, and is largely unreviewable. Preemptive pardons are granted before conviction or even before prosecution for alleged offences; they are controversial and their scope differs between the two systems.
Indian secularism is positive and reformist: the state has no official religion, guarantees freedom of religion under Articles 25 to 28, and may intervene to ensure equality and social reform, as in temple entry, triple talaq and untouchability. It treats all religions with equal respect rather than strict indifference. The US model, under the First Amendment, erects a wall of separation between church and state and prohibits establishment, with greater emphasis on state neutrality. The answer should compare non-establishment, state aid and religious freedom, and note recent challenges in both countries before concluding that both models seek plural coexistence through different means.
British parliamentary sovereignty means Parliament can make or unmake any law, and courts cannot strike down legislation for substantive unreasonableness. Indian parliamentary sovereignty is limited by a written Constitution, federal division of powers, fundamental rights and judicial review. The basic structure doctrine prevents Parliament from destroying the Constitution's essential features. The answer should compare the absence of a codified constitution in Britain with India's supremacy of the Constitution, and note that both systems retain parliamentary democracy. Conclude that India blends parliamentary government with constitutional supremacy.
The President of India is elected indirectly by an electoral college of elected MPs and MLAs through a system of proportional representation with a single transferable vote, designed to ensure federal balance and secrecy. The French President is elected directly by the people through a two-round majority system, giving a personal mandate and stronger executive authority. The answer should compare representativeness, accountability, cost, federalism and stability. India's method is inclusive but indirect; France's is direct but can produce cohabitation. Conclude that each reflects its constitutional scheme and political culture.
The US Constitution guarantees equality through the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and prohibits discrimination, but it has historically allowed formal equality with limited affirmative action. India's Constitution combines formal equality under Articles 14 and 15 with substantive equality through Article 15(3), 16(4), reservations and Directive Principles. The answer should compare the role of courts, the meaning of equality and the treatment of affirmative action. Conclude that India's model is more explicitly transformative, while the US model relies more on judicial interpretation.
Convergence between Indian and UK judicial systems appears in the growth of judicial review, public interest litigation-style access, human rights jurisprudence, precedent and the protection of fundamental rights. Divergence lies in India's written constitution, codified fundamental rights, the basic structure doctrine, an independent Supreme Court with wide writ jurisdiction, and judicial appointments through a collegium, whereas the UK has a parliamentary sovereignty tradition, an uncodified constitution and a reformed Supreme Court with a judicial appointments commission. The answer should compare these features. Conclude that both converge on rights protection while diverging on constitutional foundations.
France can learn from India's positive, reformist secularism. French laicite emphasises strict separation and neutrality, sometimes restricting religious expression in public life, which can conflict with minority rights. India's model guarantees freedom of religion, treats all religions with equal respect and permits state intervention for social reform and equality, as in temple entry and triple talaq. This allows coexistence of plural identities with constitutional values. The answer should note that each model has strengths and limitations. Conclude that India's approach offers France a way to reconcile secularism with diversity and social justice.
India and the USA are both large, federal, democratic republics with written constitutions, separation of powers, judicial review, fundamental rights and multiparty elections. Yet their tenets differ: India has a parliamentary system where the executive is drawn from and accountable to the legislature, while the USA has a presidential system with strict separation and checks and balances. India has a unitary bias with a strong Centre, single citizenship and emergency provisions; the USA is a federation of states with dual citizenship and stronger state autonomy. India follows positive secularism and has a fused, integrated judiciary, while the USA has strict separation of church and state and dual court systems. Conclude that both uphold democracy but embody different constitutional designs suited to their histories.
Notes on this topic
Short, syllabus-aligned notes for a final pass before the exam.
No notes on this topic yet. The questions above all include explanations.