Left Wing Extremism is a Maoist insurgency that seeks to capture state power through armed struggle, exploiting land alienation, displacement, forest rights and weak governance. Affected people suffer violence, displacement and denial of development. Government measures include the SAMADHAN doctrine, CRPF and state police operations, development and infrastructure schemes, forest rights, tribal welfare, surrender and rehabilitation policies, and coordination through the National Security Council. The answer should stress rights-based development alongside security.
Linkages Between Development and Spread of Extremism — UPSC PYQs & Notes
Every previous year question on Linkages Between Development and Spread of Extremism from Internal Security, with answers and explanations.
Every PYQ on this topic
Attempt each question first, then reveal the answer and explanation.
Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers; answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the disclaimer.
Winning hearts and minds in terrorism-affected areas requires addressing alienation, development deficits and trust. Measures in Jammu and Kashmir include the Prime Minister's Development Package, road and power projects, tourism revival, education and skill initiatives, rehabilitation of youth, surrender and rehabilitation policy, and outreach by security forces. The answer should also mention the role of local governance, media and civil society, and the need to avoid heavy-handedness and human rights violations. Conclude that security and development must reinforce each other for durable peace.
Naxalism is rooted in land alienation, forest displacement, poverty, exploitation and weak governance, and manifests as armed insurgency. Emerging issues include urban support networks, foreign links, use of technology, extortion and recruitment of youth. A multilayered strategy should combine security operations with development, tribal rights, land reform, grievance redress, capacity building of local administration, surrender and rehabilitation, and community policing. The answer should stress respect for human rights and avoid militarisation alone. Conclude that winning hearts and minds is as important as law and order.
Determinants of left-wing extremism in eastern India include land alienation, forest displacement, tribal deprivation, poverty, unemployment, weak governance, corruption, lack of infrastructure, exploitation by moneylenders and contractors, and the failure of welfare delivery. The strategy should combine security operations with development: implementing PESA and the Forest Rights Act, land reform, tribal welfare, road and connectivity projects, education and skilling, grievance redress, surrender and rehabilitation, community policing and intelligence-led operations with human rights safeguards. Conclude that winning hearts and minds through inclusive development is as important as enforcement.
India's approach to counter Left Wing Extremism is two-pronged: security and development. Security measures include intelligence-led operations, central armed police forces, specialised anti-LWE units, better coordination among states, modern equipment and communications, and surrender and rehabilitation policies. Development measures include the Integrated Action Plan for affected districts, road and infrastructure connectivity, forest rights, land reform, tribal welfare, education, skilling, healthcare, employment and grievance redress to address the root causes of deprivation and alienation. The National Policy and Action Plan 2015 emphasises the primacy of development and the rights of tribals. Conclude that the downward trend reflects a strategy that combines firm security action with inclusive development and local governance.
Armed insurgency has survived in India's north-eastern region for several reasons: ethnic and tribal diversity with demands for identity, autonomy and separate statehood; perceived neglect and underdevelopment; land alienation and immigration concerns; historical grievances over the merger of princely states and the Naga and Mizo movements; porous international borders with Myanmar, China and Bangladesh providing sanctuaries and arms; difficult terrain and poor connectivity; weak governance and corruption; extortion and parallel economies; and external support and funding. The answer should note that security responses alone have not resolved these root causes. Conclude that insurgency persists because of unresolved identity, development and governance deficits, requiring political dialogue and inclusive development alongside security measures.
Article 244 of the Constitution relates to the administration of Scheduled Areas and Tribal Areas, with the Fifth Schedule applying to Scheduled Areas and the Sixth Schedule to tribal areas in the north-east. The Fifth Schedule provides for the administration of Scheduled Areas, a Tribes Advisory Council, special powers of the Governor to modify laws, and protection of tribal land, culture and self-governance. The non-implementation of its provisions has contributed to the growth of Left Wing Extremism. Neglect of tribal rights, land alienation, displacement by mining and development projects without rehabilitation, denial of forest rights, weak governance and absence of basic services, exploitation by officials and moneylenders, and the failure to empower gram sabhas have created grievances, alienation and a vacuum that Maoist groups have exploited to mobilise tribal communities against the state. The answer should cite the PESA Act and the Forest Rights Act as remedies. Conclude that non-implementation of the Fifth Schedule's protective provisions has deepened tribal alienation and fuelled Left Wing Extremism, so effective implementation of PESA, FRA and tribal self-governance is essential.
Notes on this topic
Short, syllabus-aligned notes for a final pass before the exam.
No notes on this topic yet. The questions above all include explanations.