The Fiscal Health Index assesses states on debt sustainability, fiscal deficit, revenue mobilisation, expenditure quality and transparency. By ranking and benchmarking states, it creates reputational incentives, informs borrowing and investment decisions, and encourages prudent fiscal policies. The answer should note that indices must use reliable data, avoid one-size-fits-all benchmarks and be linked to incentives rather than used only for ranking.
Government Budgeting — UPSC PYQs & Notes
Every previous year question on Government Budgeting from Indian Economy, with answers and explanations.
Every PYQ on this topic
Attempt each question first, then reveal the answer and explanation.
Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers; answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the disclaimer.
The revenue budget covers revenue receipts and revenue expenditure. Revenue receipts include tax and non-tax revenue, which do not create liabilities or reduce assets. Revenue expenditure includes salaries, subsidies, interest and maintenance. The capital budget covers capital receipts and capital expenditure. Capital receipts include borrowings, disinvestment and recoveries of loans, which create liabilities or reduce assets. Capital expenditure creates assets or reduces liabilities, such as infrastructure. The answer should distinguish the two and explain their significance for fiscal health.
The GST (Compensation to States) Act, 2017 guarantees states compensation for revenue loss from GST for five years, funded by a cess on demerit goods, to protect states from the transition's revenue uncertainty and secure their consent. COVID-19 reduced consumption and GST collections, causing a shortfall in the compensation fund and delayed payments to states. This created federal tension as the Centre and states debated borrowing to meet the shortfall. The answer should note the need for a revised formula, a permanent fiscal framework and trust. Conclude that the compensation mechanism stabilised GST initially but revealed fiscal federalism's fragility in a crisis.
Post-liberalisation, public expenditure management faces challenges such as rising expenditure commitments on subsidies, interest payments and salaries, limited fiscal space, revenue shortfalls, off-budget borrowings, poor expenditure quality, delays in capital spending, weak outcome orientation, leakages and inadequate transparency. The answer should cite FRBM constraints, disinvestment targets and the need to reorient spending toward capital and social sectors. Measures include outcome budgeting, transparency, expenditure tracking, better targeting and fiscal consolidation. Conclude that managing public expenditure efficiently is central to fiscal sustainability and development outcomes.
GST subsumed central indirect taxes such as central excise duty, service tax, additional customs duty, special additional duty and central surcharges, and state taxes such as VAT, central sales tax, entertainment tax, octroi, entry tax, purchase tax, luxury tax and state surcharges. Revenue implications since July 2017 include initial volatility and shortfalls, dependence on compensation cess, compliance improvement over time, formalisation, and a broader tax base, but also revenue uncertainty for states and rate rationalisation challenges. The answer should note the compensation mechanism and the need for a stable rate structure. Conclude that GST improved the indirect tax system but its revenue outcomes need continuous reform.
In the 2018-19 Union Budget, the government reintroduced the Long Term Capital Gains tax on equity, exempting gains up to one lakh rupees a year and taxing gains above that at 10 percent without indexation, to bring parity with other asset classes and broaden the tax base. On the Dividend Distribution Tax, the budget introduced a 10 percent tax on dividend income received by domestic companies from their subsidiaries, in addition to the existing DDT, to prevent cascading and ensure reasonable taxation. These changes aimed at equity, revenue and rationalisation but raised concerns about investor sentiment and double taxation. Conclude that the changes reflected a balance between revenue needs and investment promotion.
The Union Budget 2017-18, themed 'transform, energize and clean India', proposed measures to transform governance through higher allocations for rural and infrastructure, railway safety and reform, and digital payments; to energize the economy through tax relief for small firms, reduced corporate tax for MSMEs, increased allocation for MGNREGA and rural housing, and a push for affordable housing; and to clean India through measures against black money, political funding reform, a cap on cash donations, electoral bonds, and support for the Swachh Bharat Mission and clean energy. The answer should analyse these against the objectives and note implementation gaps. Conclude that the budget's measures aligned broadly with its stated objectives, though outcomes depend on execution.
The rationale for introducing the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India was to replace the multiplicity of indirect taxes with a single, comprehensive tax on goods and services, to create a common national market, eliminate cascading of taxes through input tax credit, reduce compliance costs, widen the tax base, boost revenue and growth, and improve the ease of doing business. It was designed as a destination-based, value-added tax with a dual structure, CGST and SGST, and an IGST for inter-state trade. The reasons for delay in its rollout included the need for a constitutional amendment to give concurrent taxing powers, disagreement among states over the loss of fiscal autonomy, the demand for compensation for revenue loss, disputes over the revenue-neutral rate and the exclusion of petroleum and alcohol, the design of the GST Council, and political differences and procedural hurdles. Conclude that GST was a landmark reform but its rollout was delayed by federal, constitutional, compensation and political issues, and it finally came into force in 2017.
Tax expenditure refers to the revenue forgone by the government through exemptions, deductions, rebates, preferential rates and deferrals given to certain activities or groups, which are equivalent to government spending through the tax system. It is an indirect subsidy that does not appear as expenditure in the budget but reduces tax revenue. Taking housing as an example, the government provides deductions on home-loan interest and principal repayment, exemptions on capital gains for residential property, and concessions to affordable-housing developers and to rental income. These influence budgetary policy by reducing the tax base and revenue, requiring either higher taxes or lower spending elsewhere, and by encouraging housing investment, home ownership and the real-estate sector, though they may favour the affluent and distort the market. The answer should mention the need to disclose tax expenditures in the budget. Conclude that tax expenditures are hidden subsidies that shape budgetary policy and must be transparently accounted for and periodically reviewed.
The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act, 2003, was introduced to bring fiscal discipline, reduce the revenue and fiscal deficits, eliminate revenue deficit and build a revenue surplus, ensure inter-generational equity, improve macroeconomic stability and credibility, and make the government accountable for fiscal management through transparent targets and disclosure. Its salient features include annual deficit-reduction targets, a limit on government borrowing, quarterly review, medium-term fiscal policy and a fiscal policy strategy statement. Its effectiveness is mixed. Positives include improved fiscal transparency and discipline in some years. However, targets were repeatedly missed, the Act was diluted and amended, fiscal deficit reduction was achieved partly through accounting practices and off-budget items, and the targets were suspended during crises, so outcomes fell short. Conclude that the FRBM Act improved fiscal transparency and intent but its effectiveness was limited by weak enforcement, dilution and deviation from targets.
Notes on this topic
Short, syllabus-aligned notes for a final pass before the exam.
No notes on this topic yet. The questions above all include explanations.