The wrong statement is that no separate Bill or Act is needed to change rates of taxes already in operation; such changes are made through the annual Finance Bill, a Money Bill, because no tax can be levied without the authority of law. The Appropriation Bill must pass both Houses, withdrawals from the Consolidated Fund need an Appropriation Act, and a Money Bill requires the President's recommendation.
Union and State Legislature — UPSC PYQs & Notes
Every previous year question on Union and State Legislature from Indian Polity & Governance, with answers and explanations.
Every PYQ on this topic
Attempt each question first, then reveal the answer and explanation.
Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers; answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the disclaimer.
The incorrect statement is that a no-confidence motion must set out the grounds on which it is based; the rules require no grounds and lay down no conditions of admissibility, so the motion can be moved without stating reasons. Once admitted it must be taken up within ten days, and the Rajya Sabha cannot entertain such a motion.
1. The Speaker of Lok Sabha has the power to adjourn the House sine-die but, on prorogation, it is only the President who can summon the House.
2. Unless sooner dissolved or there is an extension of the term, there is an automatic dissolution of the Lok Sabha by efflux of time, at the end of the period of five years, even if no formal order of dissolution is issued by the President.
3. The Speaker of Lok Sabha continues in office even after the dissolution of the House and until ‘immediately before the first meeting of the House’.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
All three statements are correct. The Speaker adjourns the House sine die while only the President can summon or prorogue it, the Lok Sabha stands dissolved automatically at the end of its five-year term unless extended, and the Speaker continues in office until immediately before the first meeting of the new House.
1. The joint sitting of the two houses of the Parliament in India is sanctioned under Article 108 of the Constitution
2. The first joint sitting of Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha was held in the year 1961
3. The second joint sitting of the two Houses of Indian Parliament was held to pass the Banking Service Commission (Repeal) Bill
Which of these statements are correct?
All three statements are correct. Article 108 sanctions a joint sitting to resolve a deadlock, the first such sitting was held in 1961 to pass the Dowry Prohibition Bill, and the second was held in 1978 for the Banking Service Commission (Repeal) Bill.
A nominated member can be appointed a Union minister, since the Constitution imposes no bar on this and nominated members have served in councils of ministers. The Rajya Sabha claim is wrong because the Lok Sabha too has nominated members, the Anglo-Indian nomination is to the Lok Sabha, and nominated members cannot vote in the Presidential election.
A Constitution Amendment Bill under Article 368 must be passed by each House of Parliament separately by a special majority, that is a majority of the total membership and two-thirds of the members present and voting. Ordinary, Money and Finance Bills need only simple majorities and follow different procedures.
1. While members of the Rajya Sabha are associated with Committees on Public Accounts and Public Undertakings, Members of Committee on Estimates are drawn entirely from Lok Sabha.
2. The Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs works under the overall direction of the Cabinet Committee on Parliamentary Affairs.
3. The Minister of Parliamentary Affairs nominates members of Parliament on Committees, Councils, Boards and Commissions etc. set up by the Government of India in the various ministries.
Which of these statements are correct?
All three statements are correct. The Estimates Committee is drawn entirely from the Lok Sabha while the Public Accounts and Public Undertakings Committees include Rajya Sabha members, the Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs works under the Cabinet Committee on Parliamentary Affairs, and the Minister of Parliamentary Affairs nominates MPs to various committees and boards.
Under Article 83(2) the term of the Lok Sabha can be extended by one year at a time during a proclamation of emergency, and not beyond six months after the emergency ceases. It cannot be extended by six months or two years at a time, and extension is possible, so the first option is also wrong.
Consultative Committees of members of Parliament for Railway Zones are constituted by the Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, which services all such committees of Parliament. The President, the Ministry of Railways and the Ministry of Transport do not constitute them. Hence the Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs.
Parliament controls administration mainly through its committee system: departmentally related standing committees, the Public Accounts Committee, the Estimates Committee and the Committee on Public Undertakings scrutinise spending and administration in detail. Consultative committees are merely advisory, periodic reports are not a control device in themselves, and Parliament cannot compel the executive to issue writs.
A Money Bill can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha, on the recommendation of the President, so the statement that it can be tabled in either House is not correct. The Speaker certifies whether a bill is a Money Bill, the Rajya Sabha must return it within 14 days without amending it, and the President cannot return it for reconsideration.
Article 253 empowers Parliament to legislate for the whole or any part of India for implementing an international treaty or agreement, and such a law can be passed without the consent of any state. This is a deliberate exception to the federal division of powers, because foreign affairs are a Union subject and treaties cannot be blocked by states.
Madhya Pradesh, with the largest tribal population among the states, had the largest number of Lok Sabha seats reserved for Scheduled Tribes. Uttar Pradesh has the largest total strength of seats but a much smaller tribal share, and Bihar and Gujarat have far fewer ST-reserved constituencies. Hence Madhya Pradesh is the correct answer.
When the Speaker asks a member who is speaking to resume his seat so that another member may speak, the member is said to yield the floor. Decorum refers to orderly conduct in the House, crossing the floor means changing party allegiance, and interpellation is a formal question put to a minister. Hence yielding the floor is the correct term.
A Prime Minister who sits in the Rajya Sabha can speak on the Budget and make statements in either House, but he cannot vote on a no-confidence motion because that motion is moved and decided only in the Lok Sabha. There is no requirement to enter the Lok Sabha; the six-month rule demands membership of either House, which he already holds.
Germany has a constructive vote of no confidence: the Bundestag can remove a Chancellor only if it simultaneously elects a successor by absolute majority, which prevents a government being toppled without an alternative ready to take office. France, Italy and Portugal do not attach this condition to a no-confidence vote.
Seats reserved for the Scheduled Castes in a state are in proportion to their share of its population, which is about 15 per cent at the national level; for a state with 42 seats this gives roughly 6 reserved seats. The figures 21, 14 and 17 would imply far higher Scheduled Caste proportions.
A candidate forfeits the security deposit if he polls less than one-sixth of the valid votes in the constituency. Where a very large number of candidates contest, the votes are split so thinly that even the winner may fall below this threshold, which explains how an elected candidate can lose his deposit. Poor polling or a narrow victory alone would not cause this.
Madhya Pradesh abolished its Legislative Council in 1985 and has not revived it, although the Seventh Amendment listed it among the States that might have one. Maharashtra, Bihar and Karnataka all had Legislative Councils at the time, so Madhya Pradesh is the exception asked for.
Elected members of the Lower House of a State Legislature, the MLAs, form the electoral college for the Rajya Sabha and also vote as ordinary electors in Lok Sabha elections, so they qualify on both counts. Members of Parliament cannot vote in Rajya Sabha elections, and MLCs are not part of the Rajya Sabha electoral college.
Which one of the following will fit in the place marked ‘X’?
(Figure-based question — image not shown here.)
The missing entry is the representatives of Union Territories. Article 80 provides that the Rajya Sabha shall have not more than 250 members, of whom 12 are nominated by the President, not more than 238 represent States and Union Territories, and not more than 20 represent Union Territories. Ministers, nominated members and the Attorney General do not fit that place in the table.
Notes on this topic
Short, syllabus-aligned notes for a final pass before the exam.
No notes on this topic yet. The questions above all include explanations.