Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers;
answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the
disclaimer.
Consider the following statements: [2005] 1. There are 25 High Courts in India. 2. Punjab, Haryana and the Union Territory of Chandigarh have a common High Court. 3. National Capital Territory of Delhi has a High Court of its own. Which of the above statements is/are correct?
UPSC CSE 2005 · Prelims · GS Paper I
A2 and 3
B1 and 2
C1, 2 and 3
D3 only
Medium
Correct answer: A. 2 and 3
At the time of this question India had 21 High Courts, and the number has since risen to 25, so the first statement is wrong. Punjab, Haryana and the Union Territory of Chandigarh share the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh, and Delhi has a High Court of its own, so the second and third statements are correct.
Consider the following statements: [2005] 1. The Parliament cannot enlarge the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of India as its jurisdiction is limited to that conferred by the Constitution. 2. The officers and servants of the Supreme Court and High Courts are appointed by the concerned Chief Justice and the administrative expenses are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India. Which of the statements is/are correct?
UPSC CSE 2005 · Prelims · GS Paper I
A1 only
B2 only
CBoth 1 and 2
DNeither 1 nor 2
Medium
Correct answer: D. Neither 1 nor 2
Article 138 allows Parliament to enlarge the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, so the first statement is wrong. Officers and servants of the Supreme Court are appointed by the Chief Justice of India, but the administrative expenses of a High Court are charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State, not of India, so the second statement is also wrong as framed.
Consider the following statements: [2004] 1. The highest criminal court of the district is the Court of District and Sessions Judge. 2. The District Judges are appointed by the Governor in consultation with the High Court. 3. A person to be eligible for appointment as a District Judge should be an advocate or a pleader of seven years’ standing or more, or an officer in judicial service of the Union or the State. 4. When the Sessions Judge awards a death sentence, it must be confirmed by the High Court before it is carried out. Which of the statements given above are correct?
UPSC CSE 2004 · Prelims · GS Paper I
A1 and 2
B2, 3 and 4
C3 and 4
D1, 2, 3, and 4
Medium
Correct answer: D. 1, 2, 3, and 4
The Court of the District and Sessions Judge is the highest civil and criminal court in the district, and District Judges are appointed by the Governor in consultation with the High Court under Article 233. Eligibility requires seven years as an advocate or pleader or service in the judicial branch, and a death sentence passed by a Sessions Judge needs confirmation by the High Court. All four statements are therefore correct.
Which one of the following High Courts has the Territorial Jurisdiction over Andaman and Nicobar Islands?
UPSC CSE 2003 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AAndhra Pradesh
BCalcutta
CMadras
DOrissa
Medium
Correct answer: B. Calcutta
The Calcutta High Court has territorial jurisdiction over the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, an arrangement continuing from the colonial period. The Andhra Pradesh, Madras and Orissa high courts do not cover these islands, so Calcutta is correct.
The power to enlarge the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of India with respect to any matter included in the Union List of Legislative Powers rests with:
UPSC CSE 2003 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AThe President of India
BThe Chief Justice of India
CThe Parliament
DThe Union Ministry of Law, justice and Company Affairs
Medium
Correct answer: C. The Parliament
Parliament can enlarge the Supreme Court's jurisdiction over matters in the Union List under Article 138, by law. The President, the Chief Justice of India and the Union Law Ministry cannot do this on their own, though the President may consult the Court before such legislation.
The salaries and allowances of the Judges of the High Court are charged to the:
UPSC CSE 2002 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AConsolidated Fund of India
BConsolidated Fund of the State
CContingency Fund of India
DContingency Fund of the State
Medium
Correct answer: B. Consolidated Fund of the State
The salaries and allowances of High Court judges are charged to the Consolidated Fund of the State, so they are not voted annually by the legislature. Their pensions, however, are charged to the Consolidated Fund of India. Contingency Funds are meant for unforeseen expenditure, so those options are wrong.
The Supreme Court of India tenders advice to the President on a matter of law or fact:
UPSC CSE 2001 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AOn its own initiative
BOnly if he seeks such advice
COnly if the matter relates to the Fundamental Rights of citizens
DOnly if the issue poses a threat to the unity and integrity of the country
Medium
Correct answer: B. Only if he seeks such advice
Under Article 143 the President may refer a question of law or fact to the Supreme Court for its advisory opinion, and the Court gives advice only when he seeks it, never on its own initiative. The advisory jurisdiction is not confined to fundamental rights or to threats to national unity, and the advice tendered is not binding on the President.
Consider the following statements regarding the High Courts in India: [2001] I. There are eighteen High Courts in the country. II. Three of them have jurisdiction over more than one State. III. No Union Territory has a High Court of its own. IV. Judges of the High Court hold office till the age of 62. Which of these statements is/are correct?
UPSC CSE 2001 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AII and IV
BII and III
CI and IV
DIV only
Medium
Correct answer: A. II and IV
Punjab and Haryana have a common High Court, Bombay covers Maharashtra and Goa, and Guwahati covered several northeastern States, so more than one High Court had jurisdiction over more than one State, and High Court judges hold office till the age of 62. Delhi had a High Court of its own and the number of High Courts was more than eighteen, so the first and third statements are wrong.
Assertion (A): Willful disobedience or non-compliance of Court Orders and use of derogatory language about judicial behaviour amounts to Contempt of Court. [1997] Reason (R): Judicial activism cannot be practised without arming the judiciary with punitive powers to punish contemptuous behaviour. In the context of the above two statements, which one of the following is correct?
UPSC CSE 1997 · Prelims · GS Paper I
ABoth A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
BBoth A and R are true, but R is not a correct explanation of A
CA is true, but R is false
DA is false, but R is true
Medium
Correct answer: B. Both A and R are true, but R is not a correct explanation of A
Willful disobedience of a court order and use of derogatory language about judicial conduct do amount to contempt, so the assertion is true. The reason is also true as a general proposition, since the contempt power protects the authority of courts and makes judicial activism possible. However, contempt liability rests on the need to uphold the dignity of the courts and obedience to their orders, not on the practice of judicial activism, so the reason does not explain the assertion.
The concept of Public Interest Litigation originated in:
UPSC CSE 1997 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AThe United Kingdom
BAustralia
CThe United States
DCanada
Medium
Correct answer: C. The United States
Public Interest Litigation originated in the United States, where courts allowed public-spirited persons to sue on behalf of others who could not approach the courts themselves. India adopted the idea in the late 1970s through cases such as Hussainara Khatoon and S.P. Gupta; it is a judicial innovation, not a British, Australian or Canadian one.
According to the Constitution of India, the term ‘district judge’ shall not include:
UPSC CSE 1996 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AChief presidency magistrate
BSessions judge
CTribunal judge
DChief judge of a small cause court
Medium
Correct answer: C. Tribunal judge
Article 236 defines district judge to include the chief presidency magistrate, sessions judge, chief judge of a small cause court, and city civil, additional and assistant sessions judges. A tribunal judge, being a member of a statutory tribunal, is not included in this definition.
When the Chief Justice of a High Court acts in an administrative capacity, he is subject to:
UPSC CSE 1996 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AThe writ jurisdiction of any of the other judges of the High Court
BSpecial control exercised by the Chief Justice of India
CDiscretionary powers of the Governor of the state
DSpecial powers provided to the Chief Minister in this regard
Medium
Correct answer: A. The writ jurisdiction of any of the other judges of the High Court
When the Chief Justice of a High Court acts in an administrative capacity his orders enjoy no immunity from judicial review and can be challenged before the High Court, whose writ jurisdiction may be exercised by a bench of the other judges. The Chief Justice of India, the Governor and the Chief Minister do not exercise such special control over his administrative acts.
The power of the Supreme Court of India to decide disputes between the Centre and the States falls under its:
UPSC CSE 1996 · Prelims · GS Paper I
AAdvisory jurisdiction
BAppellate jurisdiction
COriginal jurisdiction
DConstitutional jurisdiction
Medium
Correct answer: C. Original jurisdiction
Disputes between the Centre and the states, or between two states, are heard by the Supreme Court under its original jurisdiction in Article 131, so the case begins there rather than coming by appeal. Advisory jurisdiction concerns Presidential references, and appellate jurisdiction concerns appeals from lower courts.