The NCSC and NCST have investigative, advisory and reporting powers, but their recommendations are largely non-binding, they lack independent prosecution powers and their effectiveness depends on government action. This limits their ability to secure substantive equality. Measures include statutory enforcement powers, independent investigation and prosecution, timely appointments, adequate staff, stronger coordination with police and courts, and follow-up mechanisms on their reports.
Previous Year Questions
Prelims questions are objective MCQs; Mains questions are descriptive and test answer writing. Choose a stage, then filter by subject, topic and year.
Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers for study and commentary. Answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC keys — see the disclaimer.
The Attorney General is the chief legal adviser to the Union Government, appears for it in the Supreme Court and advises on legal policy. He has the right to speak in both Houses and committees but cannot vote, and he is not a full-time government servant. Limitations include acting on government instructions, avoiding private practice that conflicts with his office, and the need to maintain legal propriety and independence.
The CAG, under Articles 148 to 151, audits the accounts of the Union and states and reports to legislatures. Legality audit checks whether expenditure conforms to law, rules and sanctions. Propriety audit goes further, examining whether expenditure is prudent, economical, efficient and in the public interest, and whether discretion has been exercised wisely. The answer should cite examples such as the 2G and coal allocations, where propriety concerns dominated. Critics warn against hindsight review, but the CAG's constitutional mandate makes propriety audit essential to legislative accountability and financial probity.
The answer should recall the recommendations of the Goswami, Vohra and Indrajit Gupta committees and the Law Commission reports on criminalisation, funding, expenditure, electoral rolls and EVMs. On one nation, one election, list the advantages: reduced cost, fewer model-code disruptions, continuity and reduced polarisation. Then list the concerns: dilution of federalism and state accountability, logistical complexity, constitutional amendments, and the risk of a dominant national wave. Conclude that simultaneous elections require consensus, a phased roadmap and complementary reforms such as transparent funding and faster criminal trials.
The Election Commission supervises elections, prepares electoral rolls, registers parties, enforces the Model Code of Conduct and takes action against violations. The MCC evolved as a consensus document to ensure a level playing field during elections, and the EC has expanded it through guidelines on campaigning, spending and social media. Its role has strengthened electoral fairness, but challenges include partisan allegations, enforcement limits and the need for transparency in EC appointments. The answer should cite the 2023 appointment law debate. Conclude that the MCC is effective when backed by credible and timely enforcement.
The National Commission for Backward Classes was made a constitutional body by the 102nd Amendment, with powers under Articles 338B and 342A. It advises on inclusion and exclusion of communities, safeguards constitutional protections and inquires into complaints. As a constitutional body it has greater independence, permanence and authority than its earlier statutory form. Yet its recommendations are advisory, and the 105th Amendment restored state power to identify backward classes. The answer should note capacity and data gaps. Conclude that constitutional status strengthens the Commission but its effectiveness depends on implementation.
Human Rights Commissions have contributed through inquiries, recommendations, awareness and intervention in rights violations, but they are structurally limited by being recommendatory, dependent on government for appointments and funding, and lacking prosecution powers. They often cannot enforce compliance against powerful actors, and their composition can be politicised. Remedies include constitutional backing, independent appointments, suo motu powers, stronger investigation capacity, timely reports and follow-up. Conclude that commissions need autonomy and enforcement authority to protect rights against the powerful.
The Attorney-General of India, appointed by the President under Article 76, is the chief legal adviser and lawyer of the Government of India. He advises on legal matters referred by the President, appears for the government in Supreme Court and High Court cases, has the right to be heard in both Houses and their committees, and enjoys privileges of a member without a vote. He is not a government servant and can have private practice with restrictions. The answer should note qualifications and tenure. Conclude that the Attorney-General is central to the government's legal functioning and must maintain independence and integrity.
The Finance Commission is constituted by the President under Article 280 every five years as a quasi-judicial body. It consists of a chairman and four members appointed by the President, with qualifications relating to public affairs, finance, administration and economics. It recommends the distribution of net tax proceeds between the Union and states, the allocation among states, the principles governing grants-in-aid, measures to augment state funds for panchayats and municipalities, and any other matter referred for sound finance. The 15th Finance Commission, chaired by N.K. Singh, was constituted in 2017 for the period 2020-25. Its terms of reference included using the 2011 census, considering the 2011 population and 1971 population, and addressing the impact of GST and disaster financing. Conclude that the Commission is central to fiscal federalism and equitable resource sharing.
The CAG is the guardian of the public purse, auditing all receipts and expenditure of the Union and states and ensuring accountability and transparency. The appointment process reflects his importance: appointed by the President by warrant under his hand and seal, he can be removed only in the same manner as a Supreme Court judge, on grounds of proved misbehaviour or incapacity, ensuring independence. He holds office for six years or up to 65 years, with salary and conditions not alterable to his disadvantage. His wide powers include auditing all government accounts, conducting performance and compliance audits, accessing records, and reporting to the President or Governor, whose reports are laid before Parliament or the legislature. Conclude that the method of appointment and powers together make the CAG a vital institution of financial accountability.