Source: questions are reproduced from UPSC Civil Services papers for study
and commentary. Answers and explanations are written by upscnest and are not official UPSC
keys — see the disclaimer.
Edward Snowden, a computer expert, and former CIA administrator, released confidential Government documents to the press about the existence of Government surveillance programmes. According to many legal experts and the US Government, his action violated the Espionage Act of 1971, which identified the leak of State secrets as an act of treason. Yet, despite the fact that he broke the law, Snowden argued that he had a moral obligation to act. He gave a justification for his “whistle blowing” by stating that he had a duty “to inform the public as to that which is done in their name and that which is done against them.”
According to Snowden, the Government’s violation of privacy had to be exposed regardless of legality since more substantive issues of social action and public morality were involved here. Many agreed with Snowden. Few argued that he broke the law and compromised national security, for which he should be held accountable.
Do you agree that Snowden’s actions were ethically justified even if legally prohibited? Why or why not? Make an argument by weighing the competing values in this case (250w/20m)
(Figure-based case study — image not shown here.) (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The ethical issues include whistle-blowing, legality versus morality, privacy versus national security, public accountability of secret state surveillance, the duty to expose wrongdoing and the consequences of unauthorised disclosure. I would argue that Snowden's action was ethically justified in motive, because he exposed mass surveillance that violated citizens' privacy and democratic accountability, and informed the public about actions done in their name, values that are fundamental to democracy. However, the method, unauthorised disclosure of classified documents, also endangered legitimate security and set a troubling precedent, so ethical justification does not mean legal immunity. The competing values of privacy, democracy, security and the rule of law must be weighed. Conclude that while his disclosures served the public interest, the legality of his means remains contestable, and institutionalised whistle-blower protection is the better solution.
Dr X is a leading medical practitioner in the city. He has set up a charitable trust through which he plans to establish a super-specialty hospital in the city to cater to the medical needs of all sections of society. Incidentally, that part of the State had been neglected over the years. The proposed hospital would be a boon for the region.
You are heading the tax investigation agency of that region. During an inspection of the doctor’s clinic, your officers have found out some major irregularities. A few of them are substantial which had resulted in considerable withholding of tax that should be paid by him now. The doctor is cooperative. He undertakes to pay the tax immediately.
However, there are certain other deficiencies in his tax compliance which are purely technical in nature. If these technical defaults are pursued by the agency, considerable time and energy of the doctor will be diverted to issues which are not so serious, urgent, or even helpful to the tax collection process. Further, in all probability, it will hamper the prospects of the hospital coming up.
There are two options before you:
1) Taking a broader view, ensure substantial tax compliance and ignore defaults that are merely technical in nature. 2) Pursue the matter strictly and proceed on all fronts, whether substantial or merely technical. As the head of the tax agency, which course of action will you opt for and why? (250w/20m) (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The ethical issues include the rule of law versus substantive justice, the difference between tax evasion and technical default, the public benefit of the hospital, equal treatment and non-arbitrariness, and the integrity of the tax agency. Option 1, taking a broader view and pursuing substantial compliance while ignoring mere technical defaults, appears more appropriate, because the substantial tax is being recovered, the technical defaults are not wilful evasion, and pursuing them would waste resources and harm a socially valuable project. However, this must be done transparently, within the law and on record, without favouritism, and with a written order explaining the reasoning, while issuing a warning or advisory to correct the technical lapses. Conclude that a principled, proportionate and documented approach best balances revenue, justice and public interest.
A big corporate house is engaged in manufacturing industrial chemicals on a large scale. It proposes to set upon the additional unit. Many states rejected its proposal due to the detrimental effect on the environment. But one state government acceded to the request and permitted the unit close to a city, brushing aside all opposition.
The unit was set up 10 years ago and was in full swing till recently. The pollution caused by the industrial effluents was affecting the land, water, and crops in the area. It was also causing serious health problems to human beings and animals. This gave rise to a series of agitations thousands of people took part, creating a law-and-order problem necessitating stern police action. Following the public outcry, the State government ordered the closure of the factory.
The closure of the factory resulted in the unemployment of not only those workers who were engaged in the factory but also those who were working in the ancillary units. It also very badly affected those industries which depended on the chemicals manufactured by it.
As a senior officer entrusted with the responsibility of handling this issue, how are you going to address it? (250w/20m) (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The ethical issues include environmental protection versus employment and economic activity, corporate responsibility, the right to health and a clean environment, livelihood security of workers and ancillary units, and the state's duty to balance competing interests. As a senior officer, I would address it in phases: assess the pollution and health impact scientifically; enforce the polluter-pays and precautionary principles; require the company to install effluent treatment and remediation at its cost; engage the community and workers; plan a just transition with compensation, retraining and alternative employment for affected workers and ancillary units; consider relocating the unit to an industrial area with safeguards; and support dependent industries with alternatives. Conclude that a balanced, science-based and humane response can protect both the environment and livelihoods.
It is a State where prohibition is in force. You are recently appointed as the Superintendent of Police of a district notorious for illicit distillation of liquor. The illicit liquor leads to many deaths, reported and unreported, and causes a major problem for the district authorities.
The approach till now had been to view it as a law-and-order problem and tackle it accordingly. Raids, arrests, police cases, and criminal trials – all these had only limited impact. The problem remains as serious as ever.
Your inspections show that the parts of the district where the distillation flourishes are economically, industrially, and educationally backward. Agriculture is badly affected by poor irrigation facilities. Frequent clashes among communities gave a boost to illicit distillation. No major initiatives had taken place in the past either from the government’s side or from social organizations to improve the lot of the people.
Which new approach will you adopt to bring the problem under control? (250w/20m) (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The ethical issues include the limits of a purely punitive law-and-order approach, the root causes of crime in poverty and backwardness, the state's duty to provide development and livelihoods, community trust, and the balance between enforcement and reform. The new approach should be holistic and developmental: continue enforcement against organised bootleggers and the supply chain while addressing demand and root causes. Steps include improving irrigation and agriculture, promoting industry and employment, expanding education and skilling, initiating community and social development, engaging religious and community leaders to reduce clashes, creating awareness of the harms of illicit liquor, offering rehabilitation and alternative livelihoods to those involved, and coordinating with development departments and NGOs. Conclude that combining firm enforcement with inclusive development will bring the problem under control.
Rakesh is a responsible district-level officer, who enjoys the trust of his higher officials. Knowing his honesty, the government entrusted him with the responsibility of identifying the beneficiaries under a healthcare scheme meant for senior citizens.
The criteria to be a beneficiary are the following: (a) 60 years of age or above. (b) Belonging to a reserved community. (c) Family income of less than 1 Lakh rupees per annum. (d) Post-treatment prognosis is likely to be high to make a positive difference to the quality of life of the beneficiary.
One day, an old couple visited Rakesh’s office with their application. They have been the residents of a village in his district since their birth. The old man is diagnosed with a rare condition that causes obstruction in the large intestine. As a consequence, he has severe abdominal pain frequently that prevents him from doing any physical labor. The couple has no children to support them. The expert surgeon whom they contacted is willing to do the surgery without charging any fee. However, the couple will have to bear the cost of incidental charges, such as medicines, hospitalization, etc., to the tune of rupees one lakh. The couple fulfills all the criteria except criterion ‘b’. However, any financial aid would certainly make a significant difference in their quality of life.
How should Rakesh respond to the situation? (250w/20m) (20 marks, 250 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The ethical issues include compassion versus strict eligibility, distributive justice and fairness in a resource-constrained scheme, the duty to help the deserving poor, the distinction between the letter and spirit of rules, and the need for transparency and non-arbitrariness. Rakesh's options are to reject the application strictly since criterion (b) is unmet; help the couple through an alternative scheme, charitable or discretionary fund, or the doctor's free surgery; seek a special exemption or clarification from higher authorities; or refer the case for relaxation of criteria for rare conditions. The appropriate course is to exercise compassion within the rules: explore alternative assistance, seek guidance, and simultaneously recommend a policy review so that rare and deserving cases are not excluded. Conclude that Rakesh should combine empathy with integrity and systemic reform.
Explain the process of resolving ethical dilemmas in Public Administration (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
Resolving ethical dilemmas in public administration involves a structured process: identifying the dilemma and the competing values; gathering facts and understanding the legal and institutional context; identifying stakeholders and the consequences for each; consulting the relevant code of conduct, constitutional values and laws; weighing options against principles such as public interest, justice, integrity and accountability; choosing the option that best serves the public interest and is defensible; documenting reasons; implementing transparently; and reviewing the outcome. Support mechanisms include senior guidance, ethics committees, legal advice and whistle-blower protection. Conclude that a principled, transparent and accountable process helps public servants resolve dilemmas ethically.
What is mean by conflict of interest? Illustrate with examples, the difference between the actual and potential conflicts of interest.\ (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
A conflict of interest is a situation where a public servant's private interest, such as financial gain, family ties or personal relationships, could improperly influence the discharge of official duties, undermining impartiality and public trust. An actual conflict exists when the private interest is directly and presently influencing or has influenced a decision, for example an officer awarding a contract to his own firm or a relative. A potential conflict exists when a situation could foreseeably arise where private interest might influence duty, even if it has not yet occurred, for example an officer whose spouse works in a company that may later bid for a contract. The answer should note that potential conflicts must be disclosed and avoided. Conclude that recognising both types is essential to preserve integrity.
“The Right to Information Act is not all about citizens’ empowerment alone, it essentially redefines the concept of accountability. Discuss (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
The statement is valid. The RTI Act empowers citizens by giving them the right to access information, making them active participants in governance rather than passive recipients, and enabling them to question decisions, expose corruption and demand entitlements. More fundamentally, it redefines accountability: instead of accountability flowing only upward through internal hierarchies or periodic elections, it becomes continuous, citizen-driven and horizontal, with public authorities obliged to disclose, respond within time limits and justify their actions. It shifts the culture from secrecy to transparency and makes officials answerable to the public directly. Conclude that RTI transforms accountability from a bureaucratic formality into a democratic right and a continuous obligation.
Distinguish between “Code of ethics” and “Code of conduct” with suitable examples (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
A code of ethics is a set of broad, aspirational principles and values that guide behaviour and decision-making, such as integrity, impartiality, accountability and compassion, describing what one ought to do. A code of conduct is a specific, enforceable set of rules and standards prescribing what employees must or must not do, with penalties for violation. The code of ethics inspires and guides, while the code of conduct regulates and disciplines. For example, 'maintain integrity and avoid conflict of interest' is ethics, while 'do not accept gifts above a specified value' is conduct. Conclude that both are complementary: ethics provides the spirit, conduct provides the enforceable rules for ethical governance.
Suppose the Government of India is thinking of constructing a dam in a mountain valley bond by forests and inhabited by ethnic communities. What rational policy should it resort to in dealing with unforeseen contingencies (10 marks, 150 words)
UPSC CSE 2018 · Mains · GS Paper IV
Medium
Approach
A rational policy for a dam in a forested valley inhabited by ethnic communities must balance development with rights, ecology and justice. Steps include comprehensive environmental and social impact assessment, free prior informed consent and meaningful consultation with affected communities, recognition of forest and land rights under the Forest Rights Act and PESA, fair and adequate rehabilitation and resettlement with livelihood restoration, biodiversity and wildlife mitigation, compensation and benefit sharing, and transparent cost-benefit analysis. For unforeseen contingencies, the policy should provide contingency funds, adaptive management, grievance redress, independent monitoring and a clear disaster and safety plan. Conclude that such a policy must place justice, consent and sustainability at its core.